Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
[x]

deviantART

 
About Me Member Traditional Artist chelakittyFemale/United States Recent Activity Deviant for 3 Years
Needs Premium Membership
Statistics 61 Deviations
192 Comments
1,795 Pageviews

New Moon: More of a Rant than a Critique

Tue Jun 23, 2009, 4:05 PM
Well, I read the second one. I love the idea, but this one irritated the hell out of me. My chief complaint: The comparison of the two character to Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet. First off, that is SO not original. So many people use that comparison, and what's worse, Shakespeare ripped those characters off of two other writers. Lets see some originality! How about Psyche and Cupid? Orpheus and Eurydice? You think 60 years down the line you'll hear someone say, "They're a regular Bella and Edward?" HELL no. And that is because the author was content to stop there are not push the archetypal envelope.

Additionally, the tragedy Romeo and Juliet took place in the 1500's. Times have changed. Yes, I do understand the basic plot; Edward is a vampire, therefore stealthier, deadlier, faster, stronger, etc. than Bella. It's the 21st century. Relationships are SUPPOSED to be equal. At least here. When did it become ok for one to dictate what was best for both? <(Edward.)

You want to be a heroine in life, not a victim. Your love leaves, you go after him. Family be damned. Even Juliet did not let her life be totally dictated by Romeo's whims. Although, for what orders she did have to follow, she did have a better excuse; it was the 1500s!

When you love someone as much as Bella's character claimed to have, you don't sit there numb for months on end. You get your ass up and you go after them. What people don't seem to realize nowadays is that there are several circles of hell you gotta walk through to be with your soul mate. It doesn't matter what the circumstances are; Vampire/Human Werewolf/Human Swampthing/lawn gnome. Whatever!!!

Despite all of my bitching, it was obviously a good story. Sometimes, even a negative reaction is proof enough of that.

On to the third.

  • Mood: Outraged
  • Drinking: coffee

deviantID

No deviantID yet.

Devious Info

  • Current Residence: America
  • Interests: art, fictional writings, food, animals, etc
  • Favourite movie: Labyrinth
  • Favourite band or musician: Mostly soundtracks, currenty, Rent
  • Favourite genre of music: Almost anything
  • Favourite artist: Van Gough and Edward Munch
  • Favourite poet or writer: L.J. Washburn
  • Favourite photographer: Mike, My boyfriend
  • Favourite style of art: anime and illustration
  • Operating System: Windows xp
  • Shell of choice: I like sand dollars
  • Favourite game: Tiddly Winks and Hide and Seek
  • Favourite gaming platform: PS2
  • Favourite cartoon character: Jessica Rabbit
  • Tools of the Trade: watercolour, colored pencil

deviantART Community Board

[x]

Comments


:iconhollowpixie:
:iconjelloplz: Thanks for the watch! :iconlovesplz:

--
:iconhatchback-girl:
Thank you so much for the fave :)

--
Live, love, dance

[link]
*icon credit goes to BGArts! Love her to death!
[link] check that out too :)
:icontalaith:
hey, thanks so much for the watch! <3

--
:heart: knock 'em dead
www.tracyleequinn.com
:iconduggiehoo:
Thanks Chelsey!!!
:iconduggiehoo:
Thanks for the fave Chelsey!!!
:iconarlene2:
hello there. We are fellow friends and followers of :icon5chmee:.
I wanted to invite you to a little contest I am having. If you have talked to him much, you know what a clown Jon can be, so the whole thing is centered around him.

Take a look, and if you have time, please feel free to participate.
Just click here: [link] (the blog says to post entries there, but if you don't have myspace you can email yours to me, provided you are interested)

Thank You. :blowkiss:
-arlene2

--
:bulletyellow: [link] <- to my flickr
:bulletgreen: [link] <- to my twitter
:bulletblue: [link] <- to my myspace
:bulletpurple: arlene_miller2@yahoo.com
:iconchelakitty:
Is there a due date???

--
Blessed are they who can laugh at themselves, for they shall never cease to be amused

-----------------------------------------------------------------------
:iconarlene2:
just wanted to remind you that today is the last day to get an entry in the contes ( [link] ) if you wanted to.

have a beautiful day!

--
:bulletyellow: [link] <- to my flickr
:bulletgreen: [link] <- to my twitter
:bulletblue: [link] <- to my myspace
:bulletpurple: arlene_miller2@yahoo.com

Site Map